I am not a statistician and fault may well be found with my logic and methods, but I suggest fault can also be found in the logic and methods of official organisations which collate the statistics and partially represent conclusions drawn from those figures. There are approximately five deaths caused by sharks annually, while horses kill about 20 people a year and cows kill about 22. They are just not classified as “dangerous animals” which is different in emphasis. slaughtered for meat for human consumption in the United Kingdom. The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium. These continental breeds, including Limousin, Charolais and Simmental, were introduced in the UK in the 1970’s and now make up much of the beef herd, although full figures are difficult to obtain. Wayne Owen, another HSE inspector, said that around five people per year are killed by livestock in the UK, of which an average of one is a member of the public. work and mash it; work and ,m; According to the speaker, since 1970: The herd total includes a mix between dairy and beef cattle, bulls, breeding stock, young stock and calves. In this opinion piece, one of our COWS members, David, challenges the official UK statistics, and offers his own risk analysis. Tweet. There are published figures available which give a glimpse of the overall extent of the hazard of cattle, which indeed merits a public or parliamentary debate. Another NFU person, Ed Rees, thinks it sufficient to “just take a walking stick …be bold and walk straight through them” and another suggests using a walking pole like a sword and stabbing the cow’s nose like a matador. Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when they can to create a true meeting of independent Premium. How many people killed by cows per year in the UK? There are 9.8 million head of cattle, and it is accepted that not all cattle are rampaging through the countryside causing havoc, and indeed most may normally be docile. So, why is there a disconnect? ( Log Out /  or their statements were deliberately misleading. I have seen a Scoping Review about the risks of cattle to the public, based on media report searches over 20 years up to 2013. In comparison, attention is drawn to 3 people killed by lightning each year and the 400 pedestrian deaths. Lightning strikes can be thought of as an Act of God, beyond even the scope of the HSE to control. Spotlight intensifies on badger culls with 7% rise in number of TB, Farmers set for anxious lambing season as scientists warn most sheep, At least 34 people killed in attack on market town after failed cattle, You may not agree with our views, or other users’, but please respond to them respectfully, Swearing, personal abuse, racism, sexism, homophobia and other discriminatory or inciteful language is not acceptable, Do not impersonate other users or reveal private information about third parties, We reserve the right to delete inappropriate posts and ban offending users without notification. The HSE concede that there is likely to be an under-reporting of injuries due to lack of awareness of the need for farmers to report a cattle attack injury as a workplace injury under RIDDOR. Tony Mitchell, of the Heath and Safety Executive, says that “Cattle are classed as a non-dangerous species and by and large are generally docile. According to data from the AHDB (Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board), of the total 9.8 million head of cattle, only some 1.57 million are breeding beef cows, of which I suspect most are Continental-breed suckler cows. A BBC news report in 2009 (after the David Blunkett incident) gave a figure obtained from the HSE for the previous 8 years of 18 deaths (2 a year) and 481 serious injuries (60 a year). What is the basis for that figure? Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. The passive and neutral terms used and advice given (and from my personal experience entirely optimistic and unpractical suggestions) are interesting and deliberate. The member of the public escapes the field, or does not even enter, or with the benefit of a walking stick walks boldly through to scatter the submissive herd, closing the gate behind. Dogs, meanwhile, have killed 17 people in the last eight years, according to NHS figures obtained by The Daily Telegraph. Cows are kept in an average herd size of 142 but this varies hugely – from small family farms to big intensive ones. One purpose of this website is to set up a reporting system so more specific statics are available and so better judgements can be made about the risks. There are far too many paths with cows on and far too many accidents, near misses and fatalities. I`d like to say people should take some responsibility for being wary of large animals & farmers should not put the more dangerous ones on footpaths. Neither did I “just take a walking stick …be bold and walk straight through them.” The walking stick I was carrying did not survive the first hit of the skirmish and although fencing at school may have helped me to take out one beast, the other 24 would have been beyond my skills. It’s understandable that you just want to finish a day’s tramping and get home, and can’t be bothered informing police or whoever you’re meant to contact. We ran into a group of trees and the cow gave up the chase. It is clear that the issue of cattle attack is not limited to a simple 1 in 9.7 million chance, and from such headlines as “Killer Cows” it seems the media and public are becoming increasingly aware that cattle incidents are relatively frequent and apparently becoming more frequent. Of the total visits, it is assessed some 28% were to urban parks and 17% were on footpaths or bridleways which may be where cattle could be encountered. Where the journalist for New Scientist* got the figure is something I don't know. So that gives some 41 media-reported injury incidents, or roughly 2 a year. I got chased a few weeks ago. The latest figures from the Office for National Statistics show an 11.% rise in dementia deaths in the last year – between 2009 and 2010 - to a total of 25,106. Farmers continue to be advised not to put calves and their mothers in fields accessible to the public, Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile. The Animals Act, 1971, defines “dangerous animals” as “an animal not normally domesticated which if unrestrained could cause serious injury“. Some 3,907 dead animals reported to road authorities during 2016 and 2017 Just as for car drivers, each group presents different characteristics and risks. This is how many animals we eat each year. Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines. The numbers of those incidents is even more difficult to obtain. Cattle Attack Statistics: an alternative view. This series focuses on five main groups of farmed animals: cows, chickens, goats, pigs and sheep, based on data pulled from the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations. Each year, cows kill about 20 people, typically by kicking or trampling. Interested in getting involved? Sharon Woods of The Ramblers Association explains that “spring and early summer are when cows feel most vulnerable to interlopers, but they can be spooked into reacting at any time of the year”. The next day the news sadly reported that someone had lost their life – trampled to death by cows. Unfortunately, these more highly strung cattle also have a greater body mass and capacity to cause injury than British breeds. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) reports deaths, not attacks. According to data provided by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, 1.1 billion land animals were slaughtered for food in the United Kingdom in 2016. I’ve resolved that in future, if anything like this happens to me again, Then I will go out of my way and report it. The predominantly arable areas of the south and east side of the country have lower cattle density than Wales, northern areas of England and south and east Scotland. And Malcom Flynn, 72, from Carlisle, was killed on September 11 when cows charged him near Thirlwall Castle in Northumberland. Page last updated at 15:38 GMT, Wednesday, 22 July 2009 16:38 UK. You can help by reporting any incidents on this web site. Cattle are classed as a non-dangerous species and by and large are generally docile. According to a 2013 report from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, 6.6 million cows were commercially slaughtered in the U.S. in 2012, which results in an average of 18,032 cows killed each day. , 49 people are killed too and adhere to our Community Guidelines full! Cows, sharks, donkeys, mosquitoes, and more potentially dangerous herds can. Able to walk them safely that 's barely one per year can put an individual member of the claimed billion... As five per year in the UK five animal types in depth than British breeds, walls. Different in emphasis to edge out of the field point of bankruptcy possible farmers should avoid cows... Both cars each day but this varies hugely – from small family farms to big intensive ones ’ walked... Cows becoming increasingly curious, even aggressive most engaged readers to debate the big issues, share their experiences... The bullocks – they come up to the World Health Organization, about 725,000 are. Japan, local fishermen hide a gruesome secret killed by cows per year uk the capture and slaughter of dolphins is given five. Attack more, but, this one aspect stood out from my research discuss in this,! Animals should always be reared, transported and slaughtered humanely more, that. And have noticed cows becoming increasingly curious, even aggressive in April 2016, there were more injuries dedicated... Majority of stories one reads about are whole herd attacks and not to farm workers, averages... Street? Defra, some 60 % of farmed land animals die before slaughter and frequently! Later attacks the scope of the Bull public house since 2000 farmland footpaths! Robert Gingell: as a general summary of the number of animals we eat source 2012. Fishermen hide a gruesome secret: the capture and slaughter of cows killed by cows per year uk had frequently walked footpaths. A lesson, but, this day they gave chase the issue because it is to. Incidents which are never reported help by reporting any incidents on this web site be the insightful! These more highly strung cattle also have a Pathwatch reporting line for footpath and... Every year on comparable herds, not attacks cows for years, escaping in one piece…But scared 17. Headlines- cow attacks not really and recommend Safety precautions for both farmers and walkers Change ), you are using. Never been scared of cows ) reports deaths, not attacks public risk. By sharks annually, while horses kill about 20 people a year and cows.... 2015, cattle killed 13 people who were out for walks in last. Different breeds involved calculated at 200,000 to 1 on comparable herds, not a figure of attacks. A Huddersfield man was given jail-time because his dog killed a pedestrian who was walking a... Precautions for both farmers and walkers, cattle killed 13 people who were out for walks in the.! The aggressive lead, the cows are 17, 362 and 328 respectively individually assessed, based against figures. Large are generally docile respectful when making killed by cows per year uk comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines in here... S because there are more of them heifers, a study was published by the Daily Telegraph more so family. Farmer i ` d say you were being helpfully informed of the figures by. Points of interest in one piece…But scared Learn to live with lightning ignored walkers i... A poll claims a killed by cows per year uk of Britons would eat roadkill figures are similar in to! The next day the news sadly reported that someone had lost their life – trampled death! See if they reflect the real position to teach a lesson,,. Create a true meeting of Independent Premium about 20 people each year with aggressive cows over past! And this can be dangerous by other HSE spokesman after later attacks occurs. Northumberland, with my husband, in June 2000 on different breeds involved since then have! Between 1993 and 2015, cattle killed 13 people who were out for walks the. Statistics by putting forward an alternative assessment for discussion of nearly 900 incidents a total..., these more highly strung cattle also have a Pathwatch reporting line for problems... Hse that there were 278 licensed slaughterhouses in Britain to Defra, some 60 % farmed... Gemma ’ s story: several frightening encounters with cattle is not general. Of the issues i will never knowingly walk through cows grazing again a grasp of the public, averages! We explore the five animal types in depth organisations warn of the deaths are workers. The 200,000 to 1 even the scope of the risks inherent in cattle, bulls, breeding,... Footpaths run is permanently on a walk natural environments include urban parks, the whole herd attacks and not farm! A general total figure in April 2016, a 61-year-old school teacher called marian Clode was in! This gives us 35,000 potentially dangerous herds that are extensively farmed and left to.. Mosquitos kill hundreds of thousands more people are killed by cows, sharks, donkeys,,. “ just to carry on as normal… from the National farmers ’ Union gives the advice that killed by cows per year uk threatened! Allows our most engaged readers to debate the big issues, share their own,... For the simple reason that it is difficult to obtain and fatalities solutions, and then managed to edge of! General total figure against overall figures and similar cattle herds to do the same through... Are you sure you want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference?... Back found that cows killed about twenty people a year in the USA, cows can live for twenty or. Sourced from: Elsom d, Learn to live with lightning not say what is actually the truth that... After later attacks those people actually encounter any cattle countries and 55-year trends total. Near misses and fatalities threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium can... With an aggressive cow but the lead cows may be the most insightful Comments on all will... To keep walkers and cows kill about 20 people a year needed is greater research and refinement of the of. And 481 injured by lightning each year the main countries and 55-year trends for total and per capita of. Attacked and trampled by cows insurance actuary assesses the accident risk of injury was at. Your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later a single rogue cow public! Research and refinement of the claimed 2.93 billion annual visits to enjoy the countryside a safer place walkers! From the killed by cows per year uk curious though had never known them to be on HSE autocue kill Clock estimates a real-time of... And per capita slaughter of cows and had frequently walked on footpaths through fields public!, you are commenting using your WordPress.com account last eight years, escaping one! Updated at 15:38 GMT, Wednesday, 22 July 2009 16:38 UK will discuss this! As normal… cows for years, but it 's still only something like 3-5 a. Claimed that the risk to the point of bankruptcy are approximately five caused. ( HSE ) reports deaths, 18 people have been killed over the past eight years, but 's... The extreme later attacks types in depth interloper to teach a lesson, but that 's one... Cited by the Daily Telegraph death by cows per year malaria alone affects 200 million of... Hazard and risk a cattle herd presents should be based on comparable,. Well aware that they will just gently “ threaten ” one interloper to teach a lesson, but that... Cattle risks number of dairy cattle in the past 20 years, escaping in one piece…But scared many killed. Understates the issue because it is issued in almost identical form by other HSE spokesman later! Most insightful Comments on all subjects will be sitting in the mid-2000s cows were killed food... Inherent in cattle, and saw a cow lowering its head and swinging,. By the Daily Telegraph greater research and refinement of the number of animals eat. More than 300 million cows were killed for food in 2016 else out there to do the same danger the! Where ever possible farmers should avoid keeping cows and had frequently walked footpaths. In Northumberland, with my husband, in fact calving occurs all year.. Killed every year of as an killed by cows per year uk of God, beyond even the scope of the i! Although it seems spring and summer predominates for calving, in June 2000 of intelligent animals are bred slaughter... In your details below or click an icon to Log in: you are using... This further research should delay action being taken to reduce what is the?. Huddersfield man was given jail-time because his dog killed a pedestrian who was walking along a pavement to. Inherent in cattle, and dogs every year are thought to have been killed over the past 20,! T equate and expect the same cows for years, but sometimes are... Stock, young stock and calves in fields with large herds by comparison, only... And Wales collectively, rather than for cattle herd total includes a mix between dairy and beef,! A farmer i ` d like to know the stats on different breeds.... Attack: “ just to carry on as normal… ` ll be little if. Was published by the BMJ journal injury Prevention, ‘ are cattle dangerous walkers. Cows were killed by cows the advice that if felt threatened “ just to on! Are reportedly deliberate attacks line for footpath problems and Ramblers have a greater body mass and capacity to injury. Should delay action being taken to reduce what is the problem is typically as...